Skip to content
Modern Review

Ecological Party Triumph Spurs Deep Reflection Within Labour and Poses Queries for Keir Starmer

Political figure speaking to reporters
A senior Labour figure spoke to the media before the result in Gorton and Denton.

For the first time in history has the Ecological Party won a Westminster by-election.

This development will certainly earn its place in the annals of parliamentary contests held between national votes.

It is destined to prompt yet more intense self-examination within the Labour ranks: coming in third place was their worst-case result.

The result validates a long-standing anxiety held by certain party figures: that they would face a challenge not only from the political Right, in the form of Reform UK, but also from the Left, in the form of the Green Party.

In the seat of Gorton and Denton, precisely that has materialized.

Tactical Dilemmas for the Labour Leader

The Labour leader will be left with several immediate and long-term issues to ponder.

First, was it a mistake not to allowed the Manchester Mayor, Andy Burnham, to stand as Labour's standard-bearer? His backers at the count told me he would have been a game-changer.

Second, has Labour's intense focus on countering Reform UK left them exposed among a segment of their regular voters?

At the 2024 general election, Labour won the seat with a majority of more than 13,000 votes and secured more than 50% of the vote share.

Internal Inquest Underway

The post-mortem analysis for certain Labour MPs started in the middle of the night.

"Starmer needs to own this. He's run out of chances," one MP texted.
"Everyone knew the sole hope to beat both the Green Party and Reform was Andy Burnham. You can't claim the party of unity when you're adopting the controversial stances of Reform. 'Vote Labour to stop Reform' rings hollow when you're echoing them."

Labour's deputy leader, Lucy Powell, quickly departed right after the declaration; reporters, giving chase, calling out queries.

To be fair, she had conducted a few interviews before the result was confirmed, but once it became apparent Labour was heading for defeat.

Opposing Responses

Reform UK's candidate, Matt Goodwin, addressed journalists afterwards, branding the Green Party "extreme" and claiming that, unlike Reform, they would not be able to replicate this success in numerous constituencies at a general election.

The Green Party, by contrast, is overjoyed. A brief conversation with their relatively new leader, Zack Polanski, just moments after the voting ended revealed a confident leader exuding a broad smile.

He can now point to a result that suggests the party's rising polling numbers since he became leader have real traction. A celebration event with him and the newly elected MP Hannah Spencer is anticipated.

Broader Electoral Fragmentation

For additional proof that the political landscape is fracturing, unpredictable, and wildly competitive, consider the performance of the Conservatives.

The Conservatives secured a paltry 706 votes – just 1.9% of the votes cast – for a party that was running the country a short time back.

A final thought that will be part of the conversation in the aftermath is the allegation of significant "family voting".

The organisation Democracy Volunteers reported "worryingly prevalent instances" of this practice in Gorton and Denton, which it describes as "instances where two voters either confer, cooperate, or instruct each other on voting".

Manchester City Council, however, insisted that "no such issues" were noted by its staff at voting locations.

Labour Party Chair Anna Turley said the reports as "deeply concerning", while Reform UK leader Nigel Farage claimed the by-election was "a victory for sectarian voting and cheating".

MF
By

Michael Ferguson

Elara Whitmore is a cultural critic and freelance journalist focusing on the intersection of technology and society.

Modern Review

Type to search articles.